
The End Of The Perfect Influencer?
As influencer content adopt production's rough edges, brands must decide whether to embrace imperfection or risk losing trust
16 November 2026
From holding the mini mic in frame, to keeping unboxing bloopers in the final edit, influencer brand videos are sharing the flaws with their audiences and creating content that feels less like an ad and more like an unfiltered glimpse into someone's life.
With consumers ranking authenticity and relatability among the qualities they value most from brands, audiences have become less concerned with how polished the content is. It raises the question: should advertisers loosen up too?
“Today’s consumers prioritise reliability over gloss," Emmanuel Xirogiannis, head of influencer EMEA at DEPT confirms.
Take Little Moon’s ad created with Ella Rose. It features the use of wired headphones as her microphone, where previously microphones would have been clipped on or not visible on screen at all. For social, the rules seem to be changing.
Audiences used to creator content now appear increasingly drawn to a version of social media that feels messy, relatable, and attainable. That shift says something about the kind of influence they trust, and creates a potential problem for brands that try to impose traditional advertising standards on creators who have built credibility by resisting them.
Some branded collabs are very simple: they might not even be edited. It could be a straight-forward short film of a creator wearing or using the product and shared with their audience.
The growth in the unpolished style is creating a conversation on how important it is to connect authentically with audiences and building trust. With 88 per cent of consumers saying authenticity matters when deciding which brands they support, the choices made in style make a difference when connecting to audiences. “That bond, between creator and audience, isn't built on perfection; it’s built on trust and intimacy. For creators to maintain that, they have to leave room for authentic connection," Tiffany Modesir, head of social strategy at VCCP Social Club believes.
Smirnoff Ice has also partnered with comedian, creator, and podcast host Brittany Broski, to allow her control of its Halloween campaign bringing her humour and unpolished creativity to produce original content and exclusive merch. Broski has built a community of followers based on her chaotic energy and messy style that audiences enjoy and relate to, and that deepens the authenticity of the partnership. When the authentic, unpolished style that comes from the influencer shapes how the partnership or marketing is presented, it guides the audience to build a connection it's familiar with and creates space for trust to grow.
With this shift away from perfection, marketers should also be considering as much about whether they will work with creators collaboratively, as whether they are prepared to let the work look like it came from the creator, without their own involvement.
So is it time to pack up the pristine studios and the perfect scripts to let creators, and their phones, do what they do best?
The human glitch
The appeal of a creator lies in the way they naturally communicate, creating a style that feels effortless and unscripted. Mondesir calls this imperfect aesthetic ‘the human glitch’. In an era of diminishing digital trust and increasingly polished, AI-generated content, she says that “audiences are actively looking for precisely those signals.” She adds that audiences are more discerning than ever before, so those signals are more important in creating space for vulnerability and a more genuine relationship.
When audiences are looking for these signals, they’re looking for “proof of human presence”, Xirogiannis says. They convey a quiet confidence and let the consumer into something real. This shift is more important than before with AI content making content easier to reproduce, it becomes harder to distinguish what is real, creating mistrust for audiences.
A shift towards more of a present and unpolished “human presence” has not only become more popular but also more valuable. Antonia Aveline, head of Maker Bench at Edelman says AI is definitely accelerating that shift. “Trusted content has never been more important. That’s why we’re seeing a rise in it," she adds.
When it comes to ads on social media, brands have to earn attention. Audiences want to feel like it's a part of their feed, not an interruption to it. That’s why the small details matter. It not only adds authenticity but it adds entertainment and a chance to stop scrolling and to pay attention. Florette Salad’s TikTok page, for example, featuring this style in a number of their posts, following trends and embracing an unpolished style from their own employee-generated content.
Sam Regan-Asante, head of Native@AMV, explains that making something look deliberately "lo-fi" takes effort, adding that when given the room to embrace the imperfections, it signals that the creator is fully behind it. He says, “They're the creator, and they've been given the ability to create something in their world and in their own space and in their own language.”
He adds that the bloopers support the entertainment and in a world where the creative scene is exploding, with the democratisation of media, there's a push away from needing something crafted, to being able to show imperfections more.
Being in the conversation
TikTok and Instagram have re-defined the rules of what makes something relevant. From crafted algorithms, never ending scrolling down the feed, and creating deeply parasocial relationships with influencers that live in an entirely different country, the way that audiences experience content social media is very different to a time before. Melo Meacher-Jones, head of social and influencer at Iris, says consuming media has become massively fragmented and that “people simply don't use social media to connect with friends and family anymore.”
Gone are the days where it mattered how many likes on a post or the number of followers, and more about maintaining attention, for however long a video may be. Xirogiannis says that consumers don’t share TV ads in their private group chats, but instead they share raw hot-takes, relatable blunders, and genuine reactions. This shift, he says, in what consumers choose to share is why social media didn’t destroy the polished ad, the change came from audience behaviour itself. He adds, “Traditional ads sit passively on screen, while real relevance, community dialogue, and active conversion happen in spontaneous, unscripted spaces online.”
So in creating unpolished ads on social media, it’s less of a stylistic choice and more about understanding how consumers are behaving and the culture that is being created online. Being relatable not only creates a community dialogue but also gives audiences something to participate in, becoming part of the brand's culture. This is where the strongest briefs lie, where they begin to understand what people are watching, sharing and talking about.
One example of this is with Dove with its r/eal Reviews campaign. Dinara Sainsbery, global brand director at Dove, says that a slightly unexpected moment, a natural reaction, or a less-than-perfect delivery can make something feel more believable. This principle is what brought them to their campaign.
What led to its success wasn't just a collection of perfect reviews collated in one place, but that consumers could see the full picture. Positive opinions on Reddit sat alongside critical ones. “People don't expect brands to be perfect, but they do expect them to be genuine. And when brands are confident enough to embrace reality rather than edit it, trust tends to follow," says Sainsbery.
From aspirational to relatable
For creators, these strong conversations online and relationships come from their content being the most relatable and authentic. Audiences can see how this can fade away when influencers become bigger and more affiliated with the brand. The influencer becomes more polished and the audience is lost.
It's becoming less about aspirational influence and more about relevant influence. This is where the power of micro influencers plays a role in this shifting behaviour and the increase of unpolished styled adverts. Meacher-Jones says the era of the big influencer is fading away. “People are starting to become very aware that mass creators also are just like brands, and actually they're there for advertising, and they're becoming less and less trusted,” adds Meacher-Jones.
Small niche creators are not only influencing, but also teaching audiences and engaging them in a way authentically, believes Aveline who says that creators are now built primarily around information, expertise, and trust. She continues, “There’s a growing value in creators whose authority comes from what they know or their lived experience, rather than follower count alone.”
Micro influencers may have a smaller audience within their chosen niches, but they have a highly engaged community that actively seeks out and trusts their perspective. They also reflect a shift in what people value from what they see on their feeds.
Aveline says, “Brands need to adapt to these sorts of changes and work with more knowledge creators or people who are actually in the industry, who people can learn information from and actually trust.” The changes in style, showcasing what feels natural and relatable, creates a solid partnership between the creator and the brand that fits into the creators existing content and expertise, and allows audiences to trust and understand the brand's message.
The effect of AI
Inevitably AI influencers are now entering the picture, creating a difficult distinction between what is natural and what is artificial. That is leading to a growing concern that AI-generated content can make brands appear inauthentic, while emphasising the importance of a recognisable human voice in maintaining trust. As the line between human and artificial influence blurs, the signals audiences use to judge what feels authentic risk becoming harder to read.
For brands, the challenge is no longer simply how polished or unpolished their content should look, but how they can build a presence people believe in. Whilst AI can replicate the appearance of relatable influencers, it cannot replicate how audiences connect with its content. When AI creates a constructed version of relatability, it creates an engagement boundary, where audiences are questioning the authenticity of the creator behind it.
Meacher-Jones says, “Social should be a place where authenticity and realness is the number one priority”, and that's why making small changes in appearance that follow a trend of human mistake, builds more trust for audiences and makes influencers more credible in their craft in building a connection. When the focus becomes less about polished ads and more about presenting messy authenticity, it becomes more honest and intentional about what is being done by the creator. They want audiences to distinguish human error in authentic moments and find relatability in that.
The real human error of the unpolished style is not bad or lazy on purpose, it's choosing production elements to keep and loose, to make it visibly human.
Collaboration
So how is this translated into a brief and how do you find the perfect imperfect micro influencer? Marketers collaborating with influencers may try to create a brief that is carefully crafted and scripted for the influencer but may miss out on the natural and unpolished signals that come from the creator, when they are left to control their own direction.
Mondesir says creators understand the nuances, pacing, and comedic timings of their specific platforms best, so when it comes to work together, the best brands are adapting by establishing clear strategic intent and creative inspiration up front, and then handing the creative steering wheel over to the creator to help them translate that using their own voice. She says the brands getting it right need to be “co-authors, not directors”.
As for creator authenticity, Regan-Asante says that even when choosing an unpolished style, the belief still needs to be there whether the influencer would actually be a fan of the product. He explains that audiences want to see something entertaining, and adding the unpolished lo-fi style, and a few bloopers, adds to that element. “It shows the creator is still being given the control, and that's what makes it feel more authentic.” he says.
The most important aspect, beyond stylistic choices, is how well a creator conveys their own story across while the content still has to obtain a certain level of craft. For example, Miu Miu sent out PR packages to influencers including one to American influencer Luna Montana. Inside was a bottle and a branded mini mic, encouraging influencers to use it as content.
Having a brand front and centre within posts is important, but understanding that the more control placed over the influencer, the less it is likely to perform well with their established audience, believes Meacher-Jones. allowing the creator the freedom to do what is right for their audience is vital to success. However, such relationships are becoming increasingly collaborative, with creators improving their understanding of commercial language and expectations from marketers. In fact, many are freely and firmly communicating with all levels, with both audiences and brands.
“A few years ago, I would sit in a room with a creator, and they just didn't understand Adland, or they didn't understand working with clients. Now we're starting to see relationships directly with clients happening more, which allows for more creative freedom as well,” confirms Meacher-Jones.
As creators become more confident in working directly with marketers, they are better positioned to balance what the brand wants and the expectation of their audiences. They are keeping up not only with the language of marketers but with changes in style and presentation. The same understanding, however, needs to come from marketers. If creators are adapting to changes in content, style and presentation, brands must also recognise how audiences engage with content and what they value.
Aveline predicts that if brands aren't open to this kind of change, then they’re going to fall behind. Meanwhile, Meacher-Jones says that it is by participating in the requited culture that leads to success for brands. That can mean being part of a conversation that's happening and working with knowledgeable creators who audiences actually trust, that brings forward authenticity and brand desirability. It then becomes less about how unpolished ads, and more about how well they understand the brands audience.








